• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
World Tennis Magazine

World Tennis Magazine

Unique Tennis Perspectives

  • Home
  • World Tennis with Harry Cicma
  • Staff
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Forum
Home » Conflicts of interest in tennis, part II

Conflicts of interest in tennis, part II

August 23, 2011 by Charles Bricker

Not surprisingly, I received an email from an agent at International Management Group, displeased with the piece published Sunday about Mary Joe Fernandez’s television conflict of interest in commentating matches involving clients of her husband, who is a top executive at IMG.

Justin Gimelstob

“Do you really believe that Mary Joe thinks about IMG when she is commentating? You don’t think she is more professional than that?” the representative wrote, then went on to make some solid observations that several other people involved in commentating matches for ESPN also have a personal interest in certain players.

There was Patrick McEnroe, he pointed out, head of the USTA player development program. He mentioned John McEnroe, because he’s Patrick’s brother. He pointed out that Darren Cahill has a contract with Adidas, and he does matches involving players who are sponsored by Adidas.

So it isn’t just Mary Joe Fernandez, who was doing analysis for ESPN2 for Sunday’s Cincinnati final between Jelena Jankovic and Maria Sharapova, who is IMG’s most lucrative client, and he saw nothing wrong with Fernandez, the McEnroes, Cahill or anyone else doing TV commentating.

If you could crystallize the point being made by the IMG spokesman, it would be that (in my words), “Lots of people do it, so it’s OK.”

No, it’s not OK. Not just the tennis public, but the public in general is entitled to know if the people purporting to present them with media information have a vested financial interest in the people on whom they’re reporting. It doesn’t mean any of those people are doing a dishonest job, but at the very least the public deserves to know about their associations.

When talk-news maven Keith Olbermann made a financial contribution to a Democratic congressional candidate and never disclosed it to the public, he was suspended when MSNBC found out. Late last year, the Reuters news wire business branch ordered an investigation of its reporters’ possible financial interest in companies they interviewed.

No one at Reuters necessarily thought reporters were on the take, but the deep concern is how their association would be perceived by the public.

Why should it be any different in sports? Don’t tennis fans (or football, baseball, hockey, etc. fans deserve to know if there is a serious connection, particularly a financial connection, between on-air talent and players or coaches they’re presenting?

You’ve probably seen network TV news programs where information flashes on the screen or where commentators announce that they have a relative or an investment with a company which is the subject of a story. Tennis needs to do the same.

What’s wrong with a commentator disclosing information before the match. As in, “Hi, I’m Darren Cahill, and I have a contract with Adidas. One of the players today is sponsored by Adidas.” OK, now that we all know that, let’s get on with the match.

Or, “Hi, I’m Mary Joe Fernandez. My husband is a leading executive with IMG and both players today (Jankovic and Sharapova) have representation contracts with IMG.”

Or, “I’m Jim Courier, captain of the U.S. Davis Cup team. Andy Roddick, who is playing the semifinal this afternoon, is one of the players the U.S. depends on to be on the Cup team.”

Or, on the Tennis Channel, “Hi, I’m Justin Gimelstob, and I’m a member of the ATP board of directors.”

And so on and so forth. Of course, there are so many of these commentators with suspect player or corporate connections that it might leave viewers wondering whether anyone doing tennis on TV is free of a conflict.

This is a significant problem for tennis fans, but there is a broader problem as well, and that’s the incestuous relationship between the hierarchies at the women’s and men’s tennis tours and the financial interests, like IMG, who have their fingers all over the game.

IMG not only represents players, but owns tournaments, including the Sony Ericsson Open on Key Biscayne, Fla., the second most important tournament in the U.S. Would an IMG player get special consideration at an IMG-owned tournament? Tennis fans have to answer that question for themselves.

It wasn’t so many years ago that Jan-Michael Gambill, who was represented by SFX, sought a wild card into the IMG-owned tournament in Scottsdale, Ariz. — a tournament he won the previous year. It was denied and the three cards given to IMG clients.

There needs to be a wide-ranging discussion about the whole range of conflicts which infect tennis and there’s no time like the present to start talking.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Filed Under: Charles Bricker, HEADLINES AND FEATURES, Top Stories Tagged With: darren cahill, ESPN, international management group, jelena jankovic, John McEnroe, justin gimelstob, keith olbermann, maria sharapova, mary joe fernandez, msnbc, patrick mcenroe, reuters news

Neale Fraser Achieved (And Experienced) Things At The U.S. Championships That May Never Be Repeated

December 3, 2024 By Admin

By Randy Walker @TennisPublisher Neale Fraser, one of the greatest Australian tennis icons, died on December 2, 2024 at the age of 91. One of the biggest legacies may be his achievements – and experiences – at the 1960 U.S. Championships, the modern-day U.S. Open. In 1960, Fraser, described as the “crack southpaw from Australia” […]

Ukraine Wins BJK Cup Match In Texas On Same Day When Russia Slams Their Nation With Over 200 Missiles

November 18, 2024 By Admin

by Randy Walker @TennsPublisher On the same day when Russia blasted over 200 missiles into Ukraine in their ongoing invasion, the Ukrainian women’s Billie Jean King Cup national team came back to defeat Austria 3-2 in a match played forced to to be played in the United States in McKinney, Texas due to the conflict. […]

Daniel Nestor Snubbed For Tennis Hall of Fame One Year After Slightly Less-Accomplished Leander Paes Gets Inducted

October 24, 2024 By Admin

by Randy Walker @TennisPublisher Great minds think alike and while Maria Sharapova and the Bryan Brothers are no-brainer inductees into the International Tennis Hall of Fame Class of 2025, I am in agreement with great tennis minds Chris Clarey, former New York Times tennis writer, Greg Sharko, the former ATP Tour stats and communications guru, […]

24-Match WTA Losing Streak Ends For Shaui Zhang In Beijing

September 25, 2024 By Admin

by Randy Walker @TennisPublisher Shuai Zhang of China ended her 24-match singles losing streak beating American McCartney Kessler 7-6(5), 7-6(1) in the opening round of the Beijing Open . The losing streak in singles was believed to be the longest in the history of pro tennis. However, according to WTA Insider, a player named Madeleine […]

Primary Sidebar

Search the site

Randy Walker

Michael Zheng Caps Historic Sports Weekend For Columbia With NCAA Singles Title (Played In The Fall This Year)

November 24, 2024 By Admin

The Winding Final Year of Rafael Nadal’s Career Meets Its End In The Davis Cup Finals

November 19, 2024 By Admin

Ukraine Wins BJK Cup Match In Texas On Same Day When Russia Slams Their Nation With Over 200 Missiles

November 18, 2024 By Admin

Daniel Nestor Snubbed For Tennis Hall of Fame One Year After Slightly Less-Accomplished Leander Paes Gets Inducted

October 24, 2024 By Admin

More Posts from this Category

Sell your home fast in New York

Recent Posts

  • Neale Fraser Achieved (And Experienced) Things At The U.S. Championships That May Never Be Repeated
  • Common Racquet Mistakes
  • Juan Martin del Potro Bids Goodbye To Competitive Tennis In Exhibition Against Novak Djokovic

Popular Links

  • ATP World Tour
  • Tennis Grandstand
  • USTA
  • WTA Tour

Footer

Contact Us

c/o Randy Walker

Owner

1175 York Ave

Suite #3s

New York, NY 10065

Recent

  • Neale Fraser Achieved (And Experienced) Things At The U.S. Championships That May Never Be Repeated
  • Common Racquet Mistakes
  • Juan Martin del Potro Bids Goodbye To Competitive Tennis In Exhibition Against Novak Djokovic
  • Patrick Mouratouglou Talks About New Zephyrhills, Florida Tennis Academy
  • Juan Martin del Potro “Farewell Match” Against Novak Djokovic Sponsored By Aleph

Search

Copyright © World Tennis Magazine 2021 and beyond